NSE weekly catch up: you know the drill

Another week, another push south... This week it was supported by global sell-off (FTSE closed down 8% on Monday's opening). Geithner needs to start walking or he'll mess up the script for Obama.

Why would you do a stock spilt at the start or middle of a bear market? Despite strong numbers, strong momentum going forward, Equity’s announcement of a stock spilt has had the opposite of the intended effect. Its arguably the 2nd faux pax after the about doing a 2nd ipo for the principal shareholders. Apparently BDA was told or thought the idea was to make Equity less expensive. Jeez, are we NSE investors that stoopid? 142 is just a number just like 1. It only gets a meaning when you put an EPS or DPS against it. I think we are seeing the first signal that NSE has drained all the speculative retail investors leaving battle-hardened experienced investors who ignore noise.

BBK released FY08. As did NIC. Excellent results given its constrained deposit gathering capacity. PAT was up 39% on 2007 driven by 56% rise in F&C. It will give a 1 for 10 bonus share for shareholders in its books on 19th March. I would have been interested to see how the various parts did and especially NIC Capital, but I guess that will wait until annual report is on its website. NIC is a steady 30-40% growth bank doing things quietly (bought into TZ's Savings & Finance and obviously got the broker licence in ’08). Won’t surprise me if it comes in with similar growth for 2009. In terms of its peers, I'd now pick DTB, NIC and CFC in that order only because NIC still lacks NSE visibility.
Sameer Africa also released. It sells tyres. Therefore ceteris paribus, if car population goes up, tyre demand will go up. But it has to import most of its tyres so fx comes into play. It still managed to increase EPS by 5% due to “other operating income”. More at coldtusker. EABL released interims. DPS is Ksh2.50 equating to 4% yield.
Cheserem for CMA chair? I won’t say much, but this dude destroyed the best chance of ever catching Pattni & Goldenberg…
Kibz came in when NSE was circa 1,000. Will he leave it there when he goes in 2012 given that’s he seems determined to do that with everything else? Waiting is a virtual…

NSE Update

KenGen continues to disappoint. 2 years after its listing ushered a new era at the NSE, the company looks like its at a standstill. Note that even if you take off the depreciation hit it took for interim 2007/8, you'd end up with flat y-o-y growth. And I don't it has much by way of pipeline projects that will increase power output.

Merali companies, of which there are 3 at the NSE are notoriuos for under-delivering. As Everready heads to Ksh1, Sameer also has issues. Its blaming likely lower profit on events in Jan-Feb. Does that mean 1 quarter makes up its whole year? Sassini also saw lower interim profits despite only a small fall in turnover. I guess there goes Merali's plan to list one company per year...

When the CFC-Stanbic merger was announced yester-yr, there were some including me who were very excited. Over the last yr however, I've been re-examining the group and can see it has issues. The CFC Life business is seriuos drag on the it and the bank is not excitely firing on all cylinders. For Q1, group saw a 10% fall in PAT, due I suspect the fact that CFC Life continues to get hit by over-reliance on the NSE. The bank with a 10% rise, also underpeformed relative to peers.

Is it to take another look at StanChart? Notice FY saw 32% rise in PAT, comfortably above peer BBK and almost on a similar level to KCB. Then Q1 saw another jaunty 25% rise primarily driven by FX fee growth. But is it sustainable? I reckon I might just get some shares so I can find out at close quarters... After all, most other banks have seen furiuos balance sheet growth over the last yr and if the economy comes off the track, NPLs won't be far behind.
DTB is ofcourse a favourite bank share, 28% growth in Q1 is respectable.

Banks H1 Results-a detailed look

Now that several banks have announced their H1 07 results with KCB, Equity and NIC meeting expectations and BBK just below, I thought I would do a deeper dig to understand what are their key drivers. These banks (plus DTK which I'll include once it announces), serve very different strata of the economy and the questions are which is getting more bang for its capital, which one has a sustainable strategy.

1. Interestingly BBK doesn't (prudently in my opinion) accrue interest from NPLs. This masks your bad debt problem and is in effect a P&L ticking bomb should you be unable to recover the loans. This interest and other unexplained anomalies also serve to distort the net interest margin calculations for both Equity and NIC.


2. The F&C ratios look higher for Equity because although in practice this income is based on accounts held, I have used customer deposits (in the absence of customer data for BBK, KCB & NIC). In the current absence of a fees price war, Equity seems to have found a strong and sustainable income stream that is of course not subject to interest cycles.


3. Despite having different loan maturity profiles, BBK and Equity have almost similar loan loss provision rates. NIC's loan loss provision rate is worryingly low.


4. KCB has deferred tax so does that mean they are still carrying losses from previous years? Equity gets 20% tax rate due to its having listed last year.


5. NPLs and insider loans account for 28% of KCB's loan book no surprise if it was lending to the likes of Mugoya.


6. NIC's capital is threadbare (hence recently announced recap exercise). BBK is the other extreme and this may explain the loan hawking and branch opening in such unlikely places as River Road.

In other news, Sameer recovered; Standard Group beat expectations with a bumper first half but its P/E ratio looks ridiculous compared to NMG. EA Portland and Bamburi have suggested it might be a good idea to merge so they can be a world beater (or Africa one anyway). So where does that leave Athi River Mining?

Sameer FY 06 Results-Grim Reading

Is Meralli losing his so-called midas touch? A month after Everready announced lower profit than prior yr, his tyre business follows suit and announces that it made a loss.

More stock picks for 2007

EA Cables: since the takeover by the G-29, the company has taken over a TZ company to given an additional leg in its ambitions to be an east African entity again; saw dizzy price heights before stock spilt and continues to return credibly good financials. All these factors will continue over the next few years because the common denominator-majority ownership by TransCentury will want to stay for several few more years.The cons is probably the same, the G-29 involvement means that should they want to exit or become stretched by involvement in other projects the company will suffer.
NMG and DTK:both majority owned by the progressive Aga Khan. NMG will become the dominant media house in East Africa over the next few years. As with the recent bonus share issue for Diamond Trust, I believe NMG will have a share spilt at some point this year to increase the liquidity of its shares and as a capital-raising exercise for future expansions. For NMG the only issues will be barriers to its expansion namely political interference as happened in ’06 when several of its staff and journalists were denied workings permits by TZ and had to leave. DTK will be expanding operations to the region.
ICDC:formed in 1967, ICDI has acted as an investor in various businesses. It has some features of a private equity fund and those of a mutual fund. The company is currently benefiting from NSE resurgence but also owns various profitable unlisted companies that could be listed in the NSE over the coming years.
KCB:Terry Davidson’s turn-round plans are well on target. The bank is now competitive in the Kenyan market, should start operating profitably in TZ and is expanding into South Sudan. I expect further government divesture in the next few years as well a share spilt. The downside is that the bank still has a significant NPL problem of the political variety i.e. politicians and their business who owe it money. This will require political will not yet seen in the current government.
Equity: the CEO is one most visionary and able mangers in Kenya’s private sector today. He is also one of the bank’s largest shareholders. The next 18 months should see the bank’s share price rocket reflecting its performance. Post this, employees will be allowed to offload their shares and hence may see lower share price. The chinks in its armour are probably to do with its fast growth i.e. non performing loans. 2ndly its success in spreading banking to village has not gone unnoticed by its bigger rivals-Barclays has now done an about-turn and will be re-opening some of the branches it closed in the late 90s. Thus there will be increased competition for Equity.
CMC:as the middle class base in Kenya expands more and more will be buying new cars rather mitumbas. And CMC are in a prime position to benefit from this.
For stable dividend policy and share growth, one should also look-out for EABL, Standard Chartered. For speculative purposes try Sameer and Scangroup.
PS: Since my post on 22nd on NSE opportunities for 2007, Barclays has since risen by 30% as investors recognise the opportunity its price presented. Those who moved in mid to late Dec will probably see the price double in the next 12-15 months.